Why Labels Fail: Church Clarity, LGBTQ Inclusion, and the Limits of Binary Thinking in Faith Communities

Episode • Nov 6, 2017 • 56m

How ChurchClarity.org is sparking a deeper conversation about transparency, LGBTQ+ inclusion, and the theological complexities facing modern American churches. Mike Erre and Andy dissect the origins and intentions of the platform while offering thoughtful critiques around its methodology, impact, and assumptions. Addressing the polarizing affirming/non-affirming binary, this episode navigates the messy tension between the demand for clarity and the pursuit of faithful community centered on Jesus. With guest insights from progressive Christians and celibate gay believers, Mike and Andy reflect on the costs, contradictions, and consequences of forced doctrinal stances in the digital age.

Key Takeaways: • The Mission of ChurchClarity.org – Exploring the site's goal to rate churches based on their LGBTQ+ policies and how clearly they’re stated online. • Critiques from Across the Spectrum – Why progressive allies, gay celibate Christians, and even pastors question Church Clarity's labeling system. • The Cost of Binary Categorization – How terms like “affirming” and “non-affirming,” along with color-coded scores, oversimplify complex theological and pastoral realities. • Center-Set Community vs. Boundary Marking – Why Vox refuses to take an official “stance” on LGBTQ inclusion and instead invites people from all perspectives to the same table. • Can True Safety Be Assured? – Wrestling with the illusion of safety in online classifications versus the lived experiences of hospitality and harm in real church communities.

Resources Mentioned: • ChurchClarity.org – https://www.churchclarity.org • RNS Article by Barbara Wheeler – Progressive critique of Church Clarity’s effectiveness • Nashville Statement – https://cbmw.org/nashville-statement/ • Preston Sprinkle – https://twitter.com/PrestonSprinkle • 1 Corinthians 9:19–23 – Paul’s posture of becoming all things to all people for the sake of the gospel

Join the conversation as we explore how the church can move beyond rigid categories to embody the radical hospitality of Jesus. Subscribe to Voxology, leave a review, and follow us on social media for more discussions that hold space for tension, faith, and transformation.

As always, we encourage and welcome discussion. Email your thoughts to hello@voxpodcast.com, or connect with us on Facebook and Instagram.

Watch us on YouTube: VOXOLOGY TV

Grab some gear from our Merch Store

Explore the Voxology Podcast

Subscribe on iTunes or Spotify

Support the show on Patreon

Music by Timothy John Stafford Instagram & Twitter: @GoneTimothy

As always, we encourage and would love discussion as we pursue. Feel free to email in questions to hello@voxpodcast.com, and to engage the conversation on Facebook and Instagram.

We're on YouTube (if you're into that kinda thing): VOXOLOGY TV.

Our Merch Store! ETSY

Learn more about the Voxology Podcast

Subscribe on iTunes or Spotify

Support the Voxology Podcast on Patreon

The Voxology Spotify channel can be found here: Voxology Radio

Follow Mike on Twitter: www.twitter.com/mikeerre

Music in this episode by Timothy John Stafford

Instagram & Twitter: @GoneTimothy

Activity