We all get deja vu as special guest CJ returns to discuss a father/daughter story by Fernwithy. In stark defiance of the entropic principle, people sail to the East FROM Valinor. Hobbit ages are confusing. Merry is the kind of friend who will call you out on your shit.

Link to the story: bit.ly/rfrjewel

Three friends read old fanfiction that they think might be good. Sometimes they are right. Sometimes they are not.

Check out our website at bit.ly/retrofanfic and send us emails at RetroFanficRetrospective@gmail.com