Another Circuit chimes in on the issue of the FICA taxation of payments made in exchange for tenure rights as part of an early retirement package offered to teachers.  In a combined appeal of two contradictory opinions of lower courts under their jurisdiction, the Sixth Circuit upheld the lower court's finding in favor of FICA taxation in Appolini and reversed the opposite lower court holding in Klender, both cases that involved early retirement payments to teachers subject to Michigan's tenure law.The Sixth Circuit, in a 2-1 split decision, specifically called into question the Eigth Circuit's holding in North Dakota State University where payments for professor's tenure rights were held not to be subject to FICA.  We look at why the majority believes the North Dakota holding was in error, as well the reasoning behind the dissenting opinion.  As well, we consider the IRS changes to Revenue Rulings in this area, as well as how the courts dealt with the prior rulings that were applicable to these cases.The materials can be downloaded at http://edzollars.com/2006-06-17_FICA.pdf.The podcast is sponsored by Leimberg Information Services, located on the web at http://www.leimbergservices.com.