Scientifically Determining Brett's 2023 GOTY List w/ Game of the Year Alumnus Evan Tolley (Pt. 1 of 2)

What's that thing Gandalf said when he was late? 'I meant to be late so I'm not actually late you short little freak,' something like that. The Game of the Year special in which we answer the burning question, 

Are you feelin' lucky punk?