In 2015, 32-year old Henry McCabe, a Liberian immigrant who worked as an auditor for the Minnesota Department of Revenue went out with friends for a night out as his wife was away with the children. Late that evening, his wife received a strange voicemail from Henry and the strange noises meant it was not clear what the message left was. Later that year, Henry's body was found in a lake with the cause of death ruled as accidental drowning. But what really happened?