In this Summer Coolers edition of NHL Wraparound, Neil Smith and Vic Morren turn their sights to the Toronto Maple Leafs, a franchise with sky-high expectations and one of the longest championship droughts in professional sports.
Despite finishing first in the Atlantic Division with 108 points, the Leafs fell in seven games to Florida—with especially disappointing efforts in Games 5 and 7. And this offseason, the biggest domino fell: Mitch Marner was traded to Vegas for center Nicolas Roy, ending his nine-year tenure with the team.
With Matthew Knies elevated to the new "Core Four", is this version of the Leafs any closer to a Cup? Or are we staring down another April collapse?
🧊 IN THIS EPISODE:
[00:00] 2025 recap: 108 points, 1st in Atlantic, early exit to Florida
[01:00] Mitch Marner traded to Vegas, signs 8 years, $12M AAV
[02:00] Leafs add forward depth: Matias Maccelli, Dakota Joshua, Michael Pezzetta
[03:00] Re-signings: John Tavares (hometown discount), Matthew Knies (6 yrs, $7.75M AAV)
[04:00] Knies' breakout & new Core Four status
[05:00] Drops: Ryan Reaves to San Jose, Pontus Holmberg to Tampa
[06:00] Can this forward group replace Marner’s 100+ point production?
[07:00] Austin Matthews’ leadership under fire: Time to step up
[08:00] Craig Berube’s system: Can he mold this group into playoff warriors?
🔑 KEY TAKEAWAYS:
Mitch Marner is gone—and he’s not coming back. He controlled the situation, didn’t want to stay in Toronto, and ultimately forced the Leafs’ hand.
Matthew Knies is officially a franchise cornerstone. With a six-year extension and a power-forward game built for the playoffs, he must carry more of the load.
John Tavares took a massive pay cut, re-signing at $4.389M per year. His leadership on and off the ice remains critical for a group chasing postseason credibility.
Craig Berube must transform Toronto’s identity, instilling grit, urgency, and resilience. Without it, history will repeat itself again.
Austin Matthews must finally own the playoffs. He’s already a Hall of Fame talent, but postseason success has to match regular season dominance.
🎯 FINAL WORD:
The Leafs still have elite talent. They still have the most media attention. And they still have the longest active Stanley Cup drought.
If Toronto can’t break through now—with Marner gone, Berube in charge, and a reshaped core—the conversation in 2026 will be exactly the same. Time is ticking.
🔗 RESOURCE LINKS:
📺 YouTube: NHL Wraparound Channel
🐦 X (Twitter): @NHLWraparound
🎤 Neil Smith: @NYCNeil
📘 Vic Morren: Vic on LinkedIn
📸 Instagram: @NHLWraparound
🎵 TikTok: @NHLWraparound
👍 Facebook: NHL Wraparound Facebook
🏒 HASHTAGS
#TorontoMapleLeafs #LeafsForever #NHLWraparound #SummerCoolers #MitchMarner #NickRoy #BradTreliving #KyleDubas #MatiasMaccelli #MichaelPezzetta #TravisBoyd #VinniLettieri #DakotaJoshua #CraigBerube #JohnTavares #StevenLorentz #NicolasRobertson #MatthewKnies #AustonMatthews #WilliamNylander #RyanReaves #HenryThrun #PontusHolmberg #CoreFour