Listen in as we journey through the chilling events surrounding the mysterious death of Susan Jennings, a beloved member of the Yorkville community. We paint a vivid picture of the events leading up to her untimely death and the shocking revelation of her secret involvement with Edward Hartley, a member of the prominent Hartley family. Our discussion explores the complicated dynamics of Susan's relationships and the possible motives behind her murder, culminating in a tearful confession from her close friend Lillian. We also reflect on the impact of this tragic event on the small town of Yorkville during Christmas of 1977.

This heartbreaking mystery forever altered the fabric of this idyllic community, especially for the Hartley family. Join us as we unravel the layers of human emotions and relationships that led to this shocking crime. Hear about the somber trial that followed, the lingering memory of Susan, and the tragic fate of Edward and Elizabeth Hartley. Be prepared for a chilling exploration of jealousy, resentment, and the consequences of unrequited love.