Jackson Maine teeters on the edge of alcoholism as he discovers and loves a young female singer. Admir and Chris discuss Bradley Cooper's great directorial debut. Special attention is given to the performances of Cooper and Gaga, both of whom are challenged in unique ways. The organic writing and heartfelt music also take center stage through Cooper's delightful direction.The boys also debate if the critical plaudits the film has received are merited, neither able to convince the other.