Jordan and Brooke are joined by friend and producer Jose Cañas for 2003's midnight slasher. They inevitably get mired in this movie's insurmountable twist, praise director Alexandre Aja for the sheer craft on display, and debate what we should actually take away from the gory kills and final jump scare here. Plus, that weird string of mid-2000s horror remakes!

Follow us on Twitter and IG! (And Jordan's Letterboxd / Brooke's Letterboxd)
Follow Jose on Twitter!